Background and aims
According to the ICCO (International Cocoa Organization), an estimated 4.9 million tons of cocoa were produced during the 2021-2022 season. Production has increased over the past 40 years, driven by strong demand from consumer countries, particularly in Europe.
A large portion of the world's production takes place in Ivory Coast and Ghana, which account for 60% of global yields. Similarly, according to the Cocoa Barometer 2022, 92% of cocoa transits through the six largest companies, whereas Valrhona represents only 0,15% of global production.
The cocoa market is volatile because prices are liable to fluctuate due to politics, weather events, overproduction or underproduction in cocoa-growing countries, speculation, new consumer demand and so on.
By way of an explainer, we describe the cocoa industry (which includes cocoa beans and their derived powder, liquor and butter) as being structured into three parts:
- Upstream: cacao tree planting and farming, cocoa bean harvesting, fermentation and drying. Most of this takes place in the Tropics. The Cocoa Barometer 2022 estimates the average farm size in the main cocoa-producing countries at between two and five hectares.
- Primary downstream: processing of the raw beans used in the chocolate industry (cleaning, drying, roasting, hulling and grinding).
- Secondary downstream: producing chocolate and other by-products.
Valrhona is a downstream operator which has chosen to purchase the vast majority (94%) of its cocoa from producers grouped into cooperatives and associations.
The upstream sector contributes to 40 to 50 million people’s livelihoods worldwide, including 4.5 million family farmers and 14 million rural workers.
Without the long-term contracts of the like implemented by Valrhona, the world market is dominated by a handful of operators and doesn’t allow small producers to exert any influence on prices. Fluctuating world cocoa prices prevent these small-scale producers from being able to rely on a steady income and investing in better farming practices.
As a result, price control mechanisms have been put in place by the Ivory Coast and Ghanaian governments since the 2020/21 harvest to guarantee producers a minimum cocoa bean price. These mechanisms include a Living Income Differential (LID) of $400 per ton paid by all cocoa buyers, including Valrhona. Despite governments’ efforts, it remains difficult to regulate prices, and they don’t always guarantee a sufficient income for small-scale producers.
At Valrhona, we are aware that these minimum prices are not enough to guarantee a decent standard of living, and we are acting accordingly.